CRIMINAL · TAX

Tax crimes in Brazil: defense of business owners

A tax assessment in Brazil may turn into a criminal investigation and prosecution against partners, managers and accountants. Criminal defense goes hand in hand with tax defense, because the outcome of the administrative case and payment directly affect the criminal case.

Evasion and misappropriationInstallments and paymentUpdates by WhatsApp

When a tax debt becomes a criminal case

Law 8,137/1990 defines crimes against the tax system. Article 1 covers suppressing or reducing taxes through fraud, such as omitting revenue, entering false data or using fake invoices, punishable by 2 to 5 years of imprisonment and a fine. Article 2 covers lesser crimes, such as failing to pay on time taxes withheld or charged from third parties.

Under Binding Precedent 24 of Brazil’s Supreme Court, the article 1 crime only exists after the final tax assessment. That is why the tax authority’s criminal referral should only go to prosecutors after the final administrative decision. A strong tax defense may also end the criminal risk.

An installment plan requested before the indictment is accepted suspends prosecution, and full payment extinguishes criminal liability. For declared but unpaid state VAT (ICMS), the Supreme Court held there is a crime when non-payment is habitual and with intent to misappropriate.

Before you act

What matters most

Final assessment

The article 1 evasion crime depends on the final tax assessment (Binding Precedent 24).

Installments

An installment plan requested before the indictment is accepted suspends prosecution while it lasts.

Payment

Full payment of the debt extinguishes criminal liability.

Declared ICMS

Failing to pay declared ICMS is a crime when habitual and with intent to misappropriate (Supreme Court, RHC 163,334).

Sources: Law 8,137/1990, arts. 1 and 2; Law 9,430/1996, art. 83, §§ 2 and 4; Supreme Federal Court, Binding Precedent 24 and RHC 163,334.

Cases

Cases the firm handles

Investigation

Summons to testify

Accompanying partners or accountants when testifying to police or prosecutors.

Indictment

Defense in criminal proceedings

Response to the charges, evidence and arguments of lack of crime, lack of intent and individual liability.

Administrative

Defense in the tax case

Challenge of the tax assessment, which may remove the basis of the criminal case.

Binding Precedent 24
ICMS

Declared but unpaid ICMS

Analysis of habituality and intent and regularization of the debt.

Law 8,137/1990, art. 2, II
Settlement

Installments and payment

Planning installments before indictment and payment to extinguish liability.

Law 9,430/1996, art. 83
Accountant

Defense of accountants

Limiting the liability of professionals who only followed client instructions.

Do not testify about tax matters without a lawyer. Statements given in the investigation may be used in both the criminal and the tax case.

Step by step

How the firm works

  1. Diagnosis Reading of the tax assessment, criminal referral and investigation.
  2. Joint strategy Coordinated tax and criminal defense, with analysis of installments or payment.
  3. Defense Action in the administrative case, investigation and criminal proceedings.
  4. Follow-up Every relevant development explained by WhatsApp.
5,000+ cases handledTen years of practicePractice before the STJ and STFFeatured in G1, UOL, Estadão and TV Globo

Case review

Let us review your case

Answer the questions one at a time. At the end you can attach documents, which go straight to a folder in the firm’s Drive, and send the summary by WhatsApp. Everything is protected by attorney-client confidentiality.

Questions

Frequently asked questions

Is owing taxes a crime?

No. Mere non-payment is not a crime. The crime requires fraud or, for taxes withheld or charged from third parties, intentional non-payment.

Can I be prosecuted before the administrative case ends?

For the article 1 evasion crime, the Supreme Court requires a final assessment before prosecution.

Does an installment plan end the criminal case?

An installment plan requested before the indictment is accepted suspends prosecution. Full payment extinguishes liability.

Is declared but unpaid ICMS a crime?

It may be, when non-payment is habitual and with intent to misappropriate, according to the Supreme Court.

Can the accountant be liable?

Yes, if they took part in the fraud. Those who only performed routine tasks without knowing of the fraud have their own defense.

Who handles the defense?

The firm’s criminal practice, with Dr. Eduardo Prado, together with the tax practice.

Lawyer for tax crimes in Brazil

SPD Advocacia defends business owners, managers and accountants in crimes against the tax system in Brazil, with a joint strategy between its criminal and tax practices, from the administrative case to criminal proceedings.

Responsible lawyers

  • Sidnei Pedro Dias OAB/GO 48.603 · OAB/DF 68.207 · OAB/SP 501.693 · leads the firm’s cases
  • Adrielle Oliveira OAB/GO 76.298 · civil, family, business and international matters
  • Eduardo Prado OAB/GO 59.836 · criminal and electoral law

Online service throughout Brazil and for Brazilians abroad. Own office in Anápolis, Goiás, Brazil: Av. Juscelino Kubitschek, 500, Genesis Office, rooms 1506 and 1507. About the firm →